Belgium is not Japan but a nuclear disaster is never to be excluded. the question whether we should close our plants soon is hovering around once again like nuclear particles in the air.[Nieuwsblad]
The debate between several parties about nuclear energy has reared his ugly head once again . however neither of the two sides can really give hard prove their wright, that is because the future cannot be predicted. It’s a good thing that the disaster in Fukushima leads to a reopening of the debate of future energy but Belgium cannot be compared to Japan. As I said in my previous post, the Japanese engineers have made some mistakes with horrible consequences due to misplaced confidence. So these shouldn’t be generalized .Better yet,it should be taken into account. Supporters of nuclear energy said that the industry safety has changed since Chernobyl. Instead of taking drastic measures like closing down old plants we should invest in optimizing the safety of these plants.
1 in 10 nuclear plants are situated in Japan , by far the most earthquake prone nation in the world. A more urgent question here is ; was this smart FOR JAPAN.
As Ben has said, this disaster has lead to the closure of 7 power plants in Germany. If every country panics and closes down his plants a huge energy shortage will not only occur for Belgium ( who is very depended on imported nuclear energy) but for whole Europe.
So what will be the alternative for the loss of our nuclear plants? Some people are asking for more green energy like windenergy or solarenergy but all the energy produced by these sources can’t even replace the energy of one small reactor, so what is left? If we stay on the track that the small plants have to shut down in 3 years we have to fill this gap with gas. That is the only viable solution proposed at the moment for a quick replacement of nuclear plants. But wouldn’t this be taking a step back? The replacement of one source with a flaw by another source with another flaw that will conduct to the greenhouse effect.
Say we do chose for the latter, once again we’ll be dependant on other countries. Russia and the Middle East. Russia has already proven that it isn’t afraid to cut off the supply ( see Ukraine). The Middle east is very unstable right now with a war threatening.
So with what options are we left? I say we start looking for safer plants, don’t eliminate but optimize.